Prediction: Illawarra Hawks VS Melbourne United 2025-12-18

AFL Preliminary Final 2025: Geelong Cats vs. Hawthorn Hawks – A Tale of Rest, Resilience, and Ridiculousness

Parse the Odds: The Math of Mayhem
Geelong enters this clash as favorites at $1.53 (decimal), translating to an implied probability of 65.36%. Hawthorn, the underdog at $2.50 (40%), is given just a 1-in-3 chance by bookmakers. These numbers scream “Geelong’s got the edge,” but let’s not let the math dull the drama. After all, sports are where logic goes to die—and come back as a 8th-place team defying the odds.

Geelong’s dominance is no fluke. Their 112-74 thrashing of Brisbane in the qualifying final showcased a machine-like efficiency, earning them a week’s rest to polish their “Grand Final starter’s kit.” Hawthorn, meanwhile, is the AFL’s version of a Netflix true-crime doc: “How a Team from Nowhere Made It to the Edge of Glory.” Only North Melbourne (2015) has pulled off a similar finals run from 8th, but let’s not get ahead of ourselves.

Digest the News: Injuries, Momentum, and Midfield Mayhem
Geelong’s key weapon? Rest. A week off means no “Monday morning quarterback” fatigue, and their star forward Shaun Mannagh—author of three goals in their last meeting with Hawthorn—can plot revenge like a vengeful elf from The Lord of the Rings.

Hawthorn’s secret sauce? Jai Newcombe, their midfield behemoth, who averages 31.5 disposals and 3 goals per finals game. That’s like having a Swiss Army knife in a knife fight—except Newcombe’s blade is dipped in honey for extra “sweet” disposals. But can he single-handedly outmuscle Geelong’s depth? Unlikely, unless he’s secretly a time-traveling version of Gary Ablett Jr. with a PhD in chaos theory.

The last meeting? A nail-biter. Geelong won 86-79, but Hawthorn nearly pulled off a “This Is Fine” dog meme comeback. Imagine the Hawks as the dog, calmly sitting in a burning house (the game), sipping tea while the score ticks upward. Close, but not close enough.

Humorous Spin: Puns, Puns, and More Puns
Geelong’s defense is like a locked vault guarded by a sleep-deprived bouncer who’s seen one too many Mission: Impossible re-runs. They’ll make Hawthorn work for every goal, and let’s be honest—Hawthorn’s attack is a GPS that says “Recalculating…” every time they touch the ball.

Hawthorn’s underdog story is so underdog, it’s practically a Shrek spin-off: “Shrek the Frog Who Believed in Himself.” But let’s not forget, Geelong’s offense is a five-star Michelin chef, and Hawthorn’s midfield is just a guy (Newcombe) trying to order dessert at a table for 20.

The MCG, meanwhile, is Geelong’s version of Hogwarts. They’ve played enough finals here to have their own Sorting Hat: “To the Grand Final! To the Grand Final!”

Prediction: Who’s the Final Boss?
While Hawthorn’s “Cinderella story” is as compelling as a Netflix series with no ads, Geelong’s rest, depth, and historical dominance at the MCG make them the logical pick. Newcombe’s heroics will shine, but Geelong’s collective talent—led by Mannagh’s vengeful glare—will drown out the underdog anthem.

Final Verdict: Geelong Cats by 22 points. Bet on them, but if you’re feeling spicy, throw a $5 dart at Hawthorn’s “Houdini Heist” special. After all, in sports, miracles happen—just not often enough to justify betting against a well-rested Geelong squad.

And remember, folks: Hawthorn’s fairytale ends here unless they invent a time machine, draft a superhero, or finally learn how to tie their shoelaces.

Created: Dec. 18, 2025, 6:55 a.m. GMT

Pikkit - Sports Betting Tracker, Odds, Insights & Analysis.