Prediction: Monmouth Hawks VS Seton Hall Pirates 2025-11-13
Monmouth Hawks vs. Seton Hall Pirates: A Tale of Two Teams (and a Lot of Injuries)
Parse the Odds
Seton Hall (-14.5) is being handed a virtual participation trophy by the oddsmakers, who’ve installed them as a near-15-point favorite over Monmouth. The implied probability? A staggering 93.3% (based on their decimal odds of ~1.07), which feels about right given Monmouth’s recent performance. The total is set at 136.5, a number so low it could make a NBA game blush. But hey, college hoops is weird—last season, Seton Hall averaged 61.6 points (ouch) while Monmouth mustered just 70.3. This year’s spread suggests a similar defensive grudge match, with Seton Hall’s suffocating D (holding opponents to 56.7 PPG so far) clashing against Monmouth’s leaky O (shooting 35.4% from deep, which is about as effective as a sieve in a hurricane).
Digest the News
Seton Hall’s injury report reads like a cast of The Walking Dead: starting big man Godswill Erheriene (shoulder) is out, guard Jahseem Felton (injured vs. Fairfield) is done, and sophomore Trey Parker is getting minutes but nursing a preseason injury. Coach Shaheen Holloway is playing 4D chess, managing minutes like a parent rationing candy on a road trip. Monmouth? They’re missing starting point guard Kavion McClain, who’s under NCAA investigation for… well, nobody knows, but it’s definitely a Nigerian prince-level mystery. Without him, the Hawks committed 16 turnovers in their last game, which is one more than their total number of three-pointers made (5-for-21). Transfer Jason Rivera-Torres is their lone bright spot, dropping 20 vs. La Salle, but even he can’t outscore a team’s collective inability to handle the ball.
Humorous Spin
Monmouth’s offense is like a group of toddlers in a pinball machine—full of energy, zero direction, and a 100% chance of someone getting a bruise. Their three-point shooting? A blindfolded penguin trying to nest in a windsock. Seton Hall’s defense, meanwhile, is a combination of a locked door, a guard dog named “Coach Holloway,” and a “NO VACANCY” sign for points. The Pirates’ recent 82-59 win over Fairfield was so one-sided, the crowd started a conga line during the 3rd quarter. As for Monmouth’s road struggles (66 PPG on the road last season)? They’re like a vegan at a BBQ—present, confused, and sweating through their jersey.
Prediction
Seton Hall wins by ~17 points, covering the 14.5 spread with room to spare. Why? Because Monmouth’s offense is a car with a flat tire (16 turnovers, 5/21 threes), and Seton Hall’s defense is the tow truck that won’t let them change it. Even with injuries, the Pirates’ depth (led by A.J. Staton-McCray’s 13 PPG and Najai Hines’ double-double prowess) will overwhelm a Hawks team missing its floor general. Monmouth’s only hope is a hot night from Rivera-Torres and a mercy rule in NCAA basketball (there isn’t one, sadly).
Final Verdict: Bet the Pirates. Unless you’re into underdog stories where the underdog is a spreadsheet error.
Word Count: ~500
Created: Nov. 13, 2025, 6:43 p.m. GMT