Prediction: New York Rangers VS St Louis Blues 2025-12-18

Blues vs. Rangers: A Tale of Two Sieves

The St. Louis Blues and New York Rangers are set to clash in a game that promises the excitement of a spreadsheet audit and the drama of a coffee refill line at 8 a.m. on a Monday. Let’s break this down with the precision of a goalie tracking a puck and the humor of a Zamboni driver with a punchy sense of humor.

Parsing the Odds: Who’s the Bigger Sieve?
The Rangers (-141) are the chalk here, which translates to a 58.5% implied win probability. The Blues (+118) offer a 45.4% chance, leaving a 16% vig for bookmakers to enjoy like a warm hot tub after a long shift. Both teams are offensive duds: the Blues have scored two goals or fewer in eight of their last 10 games, while the Rangers have managed it in five straight. It’s like watching two leaky sieves try to hold water at a bakery—present, but useless.

The total is set at 5.5 goals, and the Under is favored (-115). Given that both teams’ offenses are about as reliable as a blindfolded baker trying to frost a cake, this feels like a safe bet. The Rangers have hit the Under in 48 of their last 86 games, which is statistically suspicious—almost like they’re conspiring with the Blues to make statisticians rich.

Digesting the News: Injuries, Fatigue, and a Goalie on a Reset Button
The Blues are playing back-to-back games, a schedule as brutal as trying to skate through a mud pit in flip-flops. Jordan Binnington, their starting goalie, last played in a 7-2 loss where he allowed six goals on 25 shots. Coach Jim Montgomery called the break “necessary to reset mentally,” which is NHL-speak for “we’re not sure what’s wrong, but we’re hoping he forgets how bad it was.” Backup Joel Hofer has a 1-0 shutout record recently, which is impressive unless you’re the Blues’ offense, which needs a wake-up call as much as a Zamboni needs a nap.

The Rangers, meanwhile, have Igor Shesterkin between the pipes—a human flywall who once saved a puck so hard it went into orbit (metaphorically). Their defense, however, is missing Adam Fox and Adam Edstrom, which is like asking a shopping cart to guard a treasure chest. The Rangers’ recent struggles (1 win in 6 games) have been less about defense and more about an offense that’s scored nine goals in six games—roughly the output of a team that’s been cursed by a disgruntled bagel baker.

Humorous Spin: Hockey’s Weirdest Bedfellows
The Blues’ top line now features Alexey Toropchenko, a fourth-line winger promoted to stardom because “hockey sense” is apparently a superpower. Imagine giving a librarian the keys to a rocket ship—that’s Toropchenko on the top line. Meanwhile, the Rangers’ Artemi Panarin is the team’s offensive spark, which is ironic because the team’s power play looks like a sparkler in a monsoon.

The Blues’ road white jerseys—worn once at home this season—are so confusing they might cause a fashion emergency. It’s like showing up to a hockey game in a tuxedo during a zombie apocalypse. As for Binnington, his last start was so惨 it made Nashville’s Predators look like a pack of teddy bears.

Prediction: The Underdog’s Last Stand?
While the Rangers’ superior road record (12-5-1 vs. St. Louis’ 7-8-4) and Shesterkin’s elite play favor them, the Blues’ fatigue and Binnington’s reset could swing this. But let’s not forget: the Rangers’ offense is about as effective as a screen door on a submarine.

Final Verdict:
The Rangers win 2-1 in a game that feels longer than a 10-hour Zamboni detail. Shesterkin makes 25 saves, Binnington looks like he’s solving algebra equations with his pads, and the total goals underwhelm everyone. Bet the Under and maybe the Rangers’ moneyline, but keep a spare change for the therapist you’ll need after this nail-biter.

“ Hockey is a game of inches, but this feels like a game of ‘hope you didn’t bet on the third goal.’”

Created: Dec. 18, 2025, 8:42 p.m. GMT

Pikkit - Sports Betting Tracker, Odds, Insights & Analysis.